Meta says it would weigh pulling encrypted services such as WhatsApp from Canada if it’s ordered to weaken their encryption under Bill C-22, the federal lawful access bill. The warning was first reported by the National Post, and Meta repeated it to the Senate’s national security committee on Monday evening.

“Ultimately, the Canadian government would be enforcing and imposing a law that it is not technically feasible to comply with and still offer secure, end-to-end encrypted services to Canadians,” Robyn Greene, Meta’s director of privacy and public policy, told senators, CBC News reports. Asked whether Meta would pull services, Rachel Curran, its head of public policy for Canada, said the company would have to “review all of our options.”

Curran told The Globe and Mail last week that weakening its encryption is “a red line for us.” She pointed the National Post to Apple, which stopped offering its Advanced Data Protection encrypted backups to new users in the U.K.

What Meta objects to

  • Secret capability orders. The bill would let the public safety minister issue confidential orders requiring providers to build surveillance and interception capabilities. Curran told senators the government’s amendments “protected just the core and not the outside layers” of encryption.
  • Metadata retention. Providers could be required to keep metadata for up to six months. Curran told the Globe that amounts to “a prospective surveillance database that treats all Canadians as potential criminals.”

Signal, which testified on the same panel, went further. “If we are forced to choose between betraying our users and leaving Canada, we will not compromise the security of Canadians,” its vice-president Udbhav Tiwari said, per CBC.

What Ottawa says

A spokesperson for Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree told the Globe the bill “does not permit or compel companies to introduce systemic vulnerabilities or so-called ‘backdoors,’” and that no obligation in it requires decrypting end-to-end encrypted information.

The bill passed the House of Commons in June and is still before the Senate committee, according to Parliament’s bill tracker. If senators amend it, it goes back to the House.

Why it matters: Until now, Signal was the only big messaging app openly talking about leaving. Meta, which owns WhatsApp, Messenger and Instagram, joining in raises the stakes for the Senate’s review, though it’s still a conditional warning, not a plan. Nothing changes for WhatsApp users today. We explained what the bill would actually require last week.