Quebecor, the Montreal company behind Videotron, Freedom Mobile and Fizz, has made an unsolicited offer to buy Telus, and both companies confirmed it Monday. Quebecor values the offer at about $19.45 per Telus share, or roughly $31 billion for Telus’s shares, which Quebecor calls a 60% premium, iPhone in Canada reports. That’s not counting Telus’s debt.

It isn’t all cash. Each Telus share would get $6.35 in cash plus 0.17 of a Quebecor Class B share, so the final value would rise and fall with Quebecor’s stock price.

What Telus says

Telus’s statement shows the talks go back months. Quebecor’s first proposal arrived in June, and a revised one came on Nov. 9. A special committee of independent directors, chaired by board chair John Manley, is reviewing it. In a letter to Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau, the board lists three problems:

  • Regulators. Manley says Quebecor has, after more than four months, “yet to explain” how the deal could be approved under Canada’s current telecom rules, and calls a review “a long and costly process” for shareholders.
  • Control. Telus shareholders would supply most of the economic value but end up with a minority of the votes, and Quebecor’s controlling shareholder would pick most of the board. Telus has had one share, one vote since 2013.
  • Value and debt. The board says the price is too low compared with past Canadian telecom deals. It also notes the combined company would carry net debt of about 4.1 times its estimated 2027 earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation.

Telus says it is still willing to talk. CEO Victor Dodig has invited Péladeau to meet on Nov. 23, and the board is also looking at other options. “No decision has been made” on whether to pursue a deal, it says.

What Quebecor says

Quebecor says it would keep Telus’s brands and its Vancouver headquarters, Radio-Canada reports, and argues the combination would create a stronger national competitor under Canadian control. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said the Competition Bureau and the CRTC would review any deal independently, Radio-Canada reports. Spectrum transfers would also need approval from Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada.

Why it matters: Quebecor sells Freedom and Fizz as the cheaper challengers to the big carriers. Buying Telus would turn it into one of the big carriers instead. That’s why regulators are the biggest hurdle, and why the deal matters to anyone paying a phone or internet bill. Nothing changes for Telus, Koodo, Public Mobile, Freedom or Fizz customers for now. Any deal would take a long time to approve, and it may never happen.