# Four carriers or three? What Quebecor's Telus bid could mean for your phone bill

> Canada got a fourth national carrier in 2023 and prices fell. Quebecor now wants to buy Telus. Here's what the data, the rules and other countries' mergers suggest.

- Published: 2026-11-17T15:03:00.000Z
- By: The Circuit Staff
- Type: Feature
- Topics: Telecom, Policy
- URL: https://thecircuit.ca/posts/2026-11-17-quebecor-telus-three-carriers-phone-bills/

By Statistics Canada's count, cellphone service in Canada costs about half what it did in 2017. The agency's [price index for cellular services](https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1810000401) fell more than a third in the three years after April 2023, the month Quebecor's Videotron took over Freedom Mobile and became the country's fourth national carrier.

Quebecor puts that number front and centre. In the [release announcing its offer for Telus](https://www.newswire.ca/news-releases/quebecor-inc-announces-proposal-to-telus-for-a-strategic-combination-834609094.html) on Monday, it says wireless prices fell 35.4% in the three years after it bought Freedom, while overall consumer prices rose 7.4%. Its argument: Quebecor drove that drop, and a bigger Quebecor will keep it going.

The trouble is that buying Telus would turn four national carriers into three, the structure regulators fought to avoid during the Rogers-Shaw merger. So the question for anyone with a phone bill is simple to ask and hard to answer: would three carriers mean higher prices? Here's what the evidence says, and what the people on each side argue.

## The offer in brief

Quebecor, which owns Videotron, Freedom and Fizz, is offering $6.35 in cash plus 0.17 of a Quebecor Class B share for each Telus share, which it valued at about $19.45 a share, or a roughly 60% premium, based on Nov. 13 prices. The offer is unsolicited and non-binding, and Telus's board hasn't endorsed it. We covered the terms and [Telus's response in detail](https://thecircuit.ca/posts/2026-11-16-quebecor-telus-takeover-proposal/) on Monday.

Telus's [statement](https://www.telus.com/en/about/news-and-events/media-releases/TELUS-confirms-receipt-of-unsolicited-proposal) says Quebecor "has yet to explain" how the deal could be approved under current telecom rules, and flags "significant regulatory and execution" risks. CEO Victor Dodig has invited Pierre Karl Péladeau, Quebecor's CEO, to meet on Nov. 23.

Investors seem sceptical too. Telus shares closed up about 13% on Monday, well short of the offer price, while Quebecor's fell about 15%, [The Canadian Press reported](https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/business/company-news/2026/11/16/quebecor-makes-cash-and-stock-offer-for-telus-worth-31-billion/). Desjardins analyst Jerome Dubreuil set his Telus target assuming a 25% chance the deal closes, [The Globe and Mail reports](https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/markets/inside-the-market/article-tuesdays-analyst-upgrades-and-downgrades-321/).

## How Canada got its fourth carrier

For years, the Competition Bureau argued that regional challengers were the main thing keeping Canadian wireless prices in check. In 2019 it told the CRTC that ["in regions with wireless disruptors, prices can be 35 to 40% lower,"](https://www.canada.ca/en/competition-bureau/news/2019/11/competition-bureau-proposes-wireless-policy-to-lower-prices-for-canadians.html) naming Freedom and Videotron. When Rogers agreed to buy Shaw, which owned Freedom at the time, the Bureau [went to the Competition Tribunal to block it](https://www.canada.ca/en/competition-bureau/news/2022/05/competition-bureau-seeks-full-block-of-rogers-proposed-acquisition-of-shaw.html), saying that removing Shaw "would remove a strong, independent competitor."

The fix was to sell Freedom to Videotron. The Tribunal accepted it, finding Videotron would be "a more aggressive and effective competitor than Freedom and Shaw Mobile," according to a [summary by the law firm Torys](https://www.torys.com/our-latest-thinking/publications/2023/01/competition-tribunal-rejects-challenge-of-the-rogers-shaw-merger). The Federal Court of Appeal dismissed the Bureau's appeal in January 2023, and the Bureau [said it still disagreed](https://www.canada.ca/en/competition-bureau/news/2023/01/statement-from-the-commissioner-of-competition-on-the-federal-court-of-appeals-decision-regarding-the-rogers-shaw-merger.html) with the Tribunal's findings.

Then-Industry Minister François-Philippe Champagne approved the Freedom licence transfer on March 31, 2023, [with conditions](https://www.canada.ca/en/innovation-science-economic-development/news/2023/03/statement-from-minister-champagne-concerning-competition-in-the-telecommunication-sector.html). "Having a strong fourth competitor does lead to lower prices," he said. Under [Videotron's undertakings](https://ised-isde.canada.ca/site/mobile-plans/en/undertakings-quebecor-media-inc-and-videotron-ltd-respect-freedom-mobile), Freedom has to offer plans at least 20% cheaper than the big three's equivalent plans in B.C., Alberta and Ontario, for ten years, with penalties of up to $200 million, and Quebecor can't transfer the Freedom licences for ten years. The whole Rogers-Shaw process, from announcement to closing, took just over two years, according to [Rogers](https://about.rogers.com/investor-relations/shaw/).

## What happened to prices

The table below uses Statistics Canada's cellular services index (2017 = 100), which tracks the prices Canadians pay for phone plans.

| Month | Index |
|---|---|
| October 2017 | 101.0 |
| October 2021 | 70.4 |
| October 2024 | 47.9 |
| April 2026 (low point) | 42.5 |
| October 2026 | 48.4 |

*Index values from [Statistics Canada table 18-10-0004-01](https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1810000401), vector 1212387935; percentages are our calculations.*

**Our analysis:** Quebecor's 35.4% figure checks out for the period it picked, April 2023 to April 2026, which ends at the index's lowest point. The index has risen every month since then, so measured to October 2026, the drop since the Freedom deal is about 26%. Over the full period since October 2017, prices are down about 52%. StatCan's [October CPI release](https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/261116/dq261116a-eng.htm) says the 6.2% yearly decline mostly reflects price increases a year ago dropping out of the comparison; prices rose 0.6% from September.

Prices were already falling before Freedom changed hands: the index dropped about 30% between October 2017 and October 2021. So not all of the decline belongs to Quebecor. Still, the carriers' own numbers show the pressure. In the third quarter, average revenue per phone was $55.22 at [Rogers](https://about.rogers.com/wp-content/uploads/Rogers-Q3-2026-Press-Release.pdf), down from $56.70, and Rogers said its service revenue fell partly because of "competitive intensity." Telus's was [flat at $57.22](https://www.telus.com/en/about/news-and-events/media-releases/telus-reports-third-quarter-2026-results). Quebecor's was $36.08, up 2.9%, as it added 136,700 mobile lines in the quarter, its biggest gain since 2010, according to its [quarterly filing](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000890746/000110465926123165/tm2628877d1_6k.htm).

Canada is still expensive by international standards. ISED's [latest price comparison](https://ised-isde.canada.ca/site/strategic-policy-sector/en/telecommunications-policy/price-comparisons-wireline-wireless-and-internet-services-canada-and-foreign-jurisdictions-2025), using fall 2025 data, found Canada's average price for a plan with 20 GB or more was $73.51 a month, second-highest among the countries it compared, and up 13% from 2024. The study also found deals 40% to 50% below average from flanker and regional brands, and the lowest regional prices were in Quebec, Videotron's home market.

## What a combined company would look like

Based on each company's third-quarter reports, Quebecor and Telus together would be the country's biggest wireless provider:

| Company | Mobile lines (Sept. 30, 2026) |
|---|---|
| Telus + Quebecor | about 15.0 million |
| Rogers | about 12.3 million |
| Bell | about 10.4 million |

*Sources: [Telus](https://www.telus.com/en/about/news-and-events/media-releases/telus-reports-third-quarter-2026-results) (10.4 million phone subscribers), [Quebecor](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000890746/000110465926123165/tm2628877d1_6k.htm) (4.62 million mobile connections), [Rogers](https://about.rogers.com/wp-content/uploads/Rogers-Q3-2026-Press-Release.pdf) and [BCE](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000718940/000071894026000014/a2026-q3xmda.htm). The companies count lines slightly differently, and smaller carriers such as SaskTel aren't included.*

By that count, the combined company would have about 40% of the lines held by the four groups. Competition lawyer Michael Osborne told [Global News](https://globalnews.ca/news/12152547/quebecor-telus-merger-proposal/) that Telus has a little under 30% of the wireless market and Freedom just under 12%, and that the combination "would definitely trip the threshold" for a presumption under the Competition Act that a merger substantially lessens competition. That presumption was added to the law in 2024.

## What happened elsewhere when four became three

Europe has run this experiment several times. A 2018 [report by BEREC](https://www.berec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/files/document_register_store/2018/6/BoR_%2818%29_119_BEREC__Report_Mergers_Acquisitions.pdf), the body of EU telecom regulators, looked at four-to-three mobile mergers in Austria, Ireland and Germany and found "at least some evidence that retail prices for new customers increased due to the merger" in all three:

- **Austria (2013):** significant price increases in 2014 and 2015. They faded as smaller resellers entered, which BEREC says suggests the remedy "took more than three years" to work.
- **Ireland (2014):** statistically significant increases, lasting only for heavy users. The resellers brought in as a remedy each stayed below 1% of the market.
- **Germany (2014):** prices for low-usage plans rose by 50% within about a year, though BEREC says the results for bigger plans were "not very robust."

The same report cites a study of the Netherlands' T-Mobile/Orange merger that found prices rose 10% to 15% compared with similar countries, and a 2016 estimate by Ofcom, the British regulator, that losing a disruptive network in a four-to-three merger would raise prices 22% to 27%. BEREC's conclusion: "a careful approach should be taken with 4-to-3 mergers."

**Our analysis:** Those markets aren't Canada, and the outcome depends heavily on the conditions attached. But the European record is the closest thing to evidence on the question, and it points one way.

## The case for the deal

Péladeau argues that the competition that matters now comes from satellites, not from three or four Canadian carriers. "There's new competition. Now competition comes from the sky, competition comes from American companies," he told [CTV News](https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/business/company-news/2026/11/17/if-telus-is-sold-to-quebecor-will-you-pay-more-or-less-for-your-phone-plan/). He said the deal is "certainly not based on increasing prices." He told the [Financial Post](https://finance.yahoo.com/news/disruption-musk-starlink-others-behind-011605999.html) that satellite players like Starlink could upend mobile service the way streaming upended cable, and that he doesn't think any divestiture should be needed, Freedom included.

Quebecor's release says the combined company would keep the Telus brands and head office in Vancouver, preserve "Canadian control of strategic telecommunications assets," and be better placed to invest in networks. It projects about $160 million a year in operating savings and $235 million in capital savings, and says it's "prepared to discuss measurable commitments" on pricing, regional service and jobs.

That pitch lines up with how Ottawa is now talking. Industry Minister Mélanie Joly's [statement on the bid](https://www.canada.ca/en/innovation-science-economic-development/news/2026/11/statement-from-minister-joly-on-quebecor-and-telus.html) stresses "sovereign connectivity from sea to sky" and says the government won't "predetermine the outcomes" of the reviews. Desjardins' Dubreuil sees "a compelling long-term strategic rationale" for Quebecor, though he expects regulatory approval to be the biggest hurdle.

## The case against

Critics say the deal would undo the very remedy that got Rogers-Shaw approved. University of Ottawa law professor Michael Geist [argues](https://www.michaelgeist.ca/2026/11/what-happened-to-competition-why-sovereignty-is-the-wrong-answer-to-quebecors-bid-for-telus/) that sovereignty is "a red herring," since all four national carriers are already Canadian, and that the deal would reduce Canadian competition without changing who owns the networks. He notes Ottawa's [Telecom Competition Roadmap](https://thecircuit.ca/posts/2026-10-29-telecom-competition-roadmap/), released less than three weeks earlier, made cross-country competition its goal.

Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi wrote that "regulatory decisions will make or break the deal," [CP reports](https://www.bnnbloomberg.ca/business/company-news/2026/11/16/quebecor-makes-cash-and-stock-offer-for-telus-worth-31-billion/). National Bank's Adam Shine told the [Financial Post](https://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/competition-questions-cloud-quebecor-blockbuster-162345547.html) he doesn't see how Ottawa can approve it.

Consumer and political voices are blunter. The Public Interest Advocacy Centre said it's "concerned about the impact on consumers in terms of prices and affordability," [per Global News](https://globalnews.ca/news/12152547/quebecor-telus-merger-proposal/). NDP Leader Avi Lewis said the Competition Bureau "must block this sale," and the president of Telus's largest union local said approval "seems doubtful," [MobileSyrup reports](https://mobilesyrup.com/2026/11/16/critics-competition-affordability-concerns-quebecor-telus/).

## What to watch

- **Nov. 23:** the proposed meeting between Telus and Quebecor executives. Telus says no decision has been made and it's reviewing other options.
- **The Competition Bureau:** it told Global News it may review any merger and will "take appropriate action" if one is likely to harm competition. - **ISED and the spectrum rules:** Quebecor's own release concedes there's still a moratorium on large spectrum licence transfers, and the ten-year hold on Freedom's licences runs until 2033, Osborne told the Financial Post. Geist notes that the minister's power over spectrum transfers is what ultimately settled Rogers-Shaw.
- **The Freedom question:** whether Quebecor would sell Freedom, or offer price commitments, to win approval. Péladeau says it shouldn't have to; Osborne told the Financial Post the deal has little chance unless Quebecor finds a buyer for Freedom.
- **Prices:** the cellular index has been rising since April. Watch whether that continues while the bid hangs over the market.

**Why it matters:** The best evidence, from Canada's own regulators and from Europe, says a fourth carrier keeps prices lower and losing one raises them, at least for a while. Quebecor's answer is that the real threat is now foreign satellite companies and that a bigger Canadian carrier can promise to keep prices down. That's a trade-off the Competition Bureau and Ottawa would have to weigh, and if Rogers-Shaw is any guide, the review would be long. For now, nothing changes for Telus, Koodo, Public Mobile, Freedom or Fizz customers, and the deal may never happen.
